top of page

Your AI coach will probably get this wrong...

Writer: Meridith Grundei
Meridith Grundei
Nov 10
6 min read

An AI tool would have told my client to sound more excited and it would have been terrible advice.


Meridith Grundei at AWS CEE Community Day 2026


This past month, an Amazon New Voices participant messaged me. They have a slow, relaxed voice. Their word for it was "podcast-y." It works beautifully on a close mic. What they wanted to know was whether they would have to turn into a high-energy host to survive a live stage.


My answer the them, was, heck to the no. You need breath behind your voice, pauses you mean, and a body that carries the energy your voice doesn't. Presence comes from commitment, not volume.


I keep thinking about that message because an AI tool would have scored that voice as "low energy" and suggested more pitch variation. Technically the AI would be right, but the feedback would have been completely wrong for this speaker. It takes a person who has seen them in action to say: keep your awesome voice, and here is how you can make it land in the room.


And there lies the argument for this entire newsletter in one DM!


A few weeks ago, the University of Phoenix released its Future of Skills Dev report, conducted by The Harris Poll. The survey covered 755 U.S. HR leaders and found that 64% are very confident they know what skills their employees need, but only 43% are very confident that employees actually posses them. Yup, go ahead and read that again, if you need to.


This means the people in charge of building capability are much more sure about the destination than about where anyone in the org. is presently standing.


The report also stated that nearly 3 in 5 (59%) HR leaders say soft or durable skills such as communication, collaboration and problem-solving are their organization's primary talent development focus, compared with 37% who believe technical skills as the primary focus.


Great! I agree, but then I kept reading and found this nugget. When HR leaders were asked which skills are hardest to verify in a candidate, soft or durable skills were at the top of the list!


Essentially, the skill most companies say they are prioritizing is the skill they have the hardest time seeing. And THIS is the gap I want to talk about. Let's go!


Let's talk about how companies measure communication today...


When I ask leaders how they know someone can communicate, I usually get a pause and then a name. "Oh, Alison is great in meetings." Or "Lucas just gave two presentations." Um, great, but are the messages landing?


It turns out that this pause is pretty normal. Half of HR leaders say they mostly rely on the manager's opinion or a performance review to know what skills people have (51%). But fewer than half think their managers are very prepared to have that conversation (49%). And only 44% say their company regularly checks for skill gaps at all.


So for the skill that everyone says matters most, we're going on a manager's gut and a yearly review (me scratching my head).


Here is, what I believe, what you are unable to see is costing you.


Did you know that U.S. businesses lose an estimated $1.2 trillion a year to poor communication, according to Grammarly and The Harris Poll's State of Business Communication research. For a 100-person company, that averages $500K a year! For large enterprises that's $62.4 million. Three in four business leaders say they spend way too much time cleaning up miscommunication, and one in five execs has lost business because their message didn't land.


You can track market spend by the decimal all day long, but what about communication loss?


And, of course, now in the age of AI, we assume AI it can fix it! It can write the email, draft the deck, and coach the delivery. Done and done!


I wanted that to be true. Well, kinda. I white-labeled an AI coaching platform directly into my programs. My clients thought it was a cool value-add and were excited to use it! And then, almost all of them stopped using it. The tool could tell them they said, "um" fourteen times but it couldn't tell my "podcast-y" participant that their voice was fine and they just needed to breathe and pause to fill a room. It would have told them to add more pitch variation and to sound more excited!


The University of Phoenix team landed in a similar place. As Nathan Jones, who leads product for its Workforce Solutions group, put it, "technology does not eliminate the need for judgment, communication, problem-solving and adaptability."


I am going to take this even further and say that AI is widening the gap between the strong communicators and the weak ones, and it is doing it super fast without our noticing it. I wrote about it in Fast Company ("AI Is Teaching Us to Speak Like Bots"). I started to notice teams who were heavy in AI workflows were super transactional with each other and their tone was clipped. I witnessed curiosity and courtesy (the special sauce for great communication), was getting lost.


Here is what I think.


Great communication does not exist in a vacuum. It only exists when it lands on another human and this means two things for anyone buying training:


First, you can't build the thing without the other human in the room. A workshop can give people a framework and a tool can give them a transcript, but neither of these gives them the thing that actually changes the behavior. Standing in front of someone real and watching whether an idea landed or not is human-centric gold.


Second, you can't verify it without other humans either. If the only evidence of communication skills is manager's opinion, you'll keep getting the 64/43 split. The actual proof has to come from the people on the receiving end.


Most corporate communication training stops right where the value starts. People attend, build the presentation, and never deliver it again or fall back into their old habits. Why? Because there are no reps, no data and nothing to certify beyond attendance.


I don't have to guess whether people want this kind of training--the proof is in the pudding! The Amazon New Voices speaker program I lead through AWS attracted 300 applicants from the builders community in 2023. Three years later, more than 900 people from over 60 countries applied. Our numbers increased while AI continued to get better. That, right there, tells me a lot!


Demand did not triple for a self-paced module. People apply because the program has a clear finish line and real humans leading them there. To graduate, participants give two live talks to a user group, a summit, or an AWS Community Day. These are real audiences. Real feedback from the people who were there.


Human connection is what people are looking for when they raise their hand.


"I used to be the last to speak in breakout rooms. I was always overthinking what others might think of me. After this program, confidence kills my doubt. I actually enjoy breakout rooms now." ~ N. Mudunuri, AWS Community Builder

Here is what I believe human-centered training looks like and this is what I have been further designing with Maxine Cunningham of Pick My Brain. It has a simple but impactful shape:


Train, Practice, Certify.


People learn The Ready Room™️, my, highly interactive, engaging communication method, and walk out with a real talk on something they actually know. Then they deliver it, more than once, to colleagues they have never met, across teams and levels. Pick My Brain makes the matches. Maxine has built matching platforms that have gotten hundreds of strangers talking, this is her jam!


Certification comes from doing the reps, not sitting through a workshop. And every conversation leaves behind something leadership can actually see and customers can actually understand.


And now here is what leaders finally get to see.


This is the part that answers the University of Phoenix report. When HR leaders were asked what makes them trust someone's skills, the biggest group said they only feel sure after some kind of real test (38%).


Every conversation in this program is that test because it happens live and in a room with a colleague.


Add those up and you get something magical that not a lot of L&D teams have: real data! Not, who logged in, but what people actually did, how they grew, and who they connected with along the way. You also get a window into what your people are learning from each other, which only strengthens your company knowledge pool.


Ok, so before I part, here are a couple of questions you can be asking in your next budget meeting:


👉 When did your organization get real feedback on whether their message landed, not just on what they said?


👉 And if you're spending money on communication training, what proof did you get back besides attendance?

​


My “podcast-y” friend didn’t need a louder voice. Your team probably doesn’t need another module. They just need reps, and someone watching.

bottom of page